Skip to the page
A tank water heater beside a tankless unit

Tank vs tankless water heater for your home

A tank heater stores hot water and a tankless unit heats it as you use it. Each suits different households, and the right choice depends on how much hot water you use at once and what your home can support.

Request a plumber quote

Fill this in and a local specialist gets back to you to quote.

So the business can look at the job and price it.

  1. Describe the job. A short form, two minutes or so.
  2. A local specialist gets in touch. They ask a few questions and quote.
  3. You choose. Go ahead only if the price suits you.

A tank water heater keeps a reserve of heated water and loses a little heat around the clock. A tankless unit heats water only when a tap opens, so it cuts that standby loss and can last longer, but it costs more to buy and install and can only deliver so much hot water at once. If you want a unit fitted, tankless water heater installation explains the work, and the sections below help you decide first.

Which is better for a home: tank or tankless?

Neither is better for everyone. Tank units cost less up front and are simple to replace, but they take floor space and run out when the tank empties. Tankless units give continuous hot water and save energy for lighter users, but they need the right gas line or power supply and a proper vent. Your usage and your house decide.

The US Department of Energy says demand-type heaters can be 24% to 34% more energy efficient than conventional storage heaters in homes that use 41 gallons of hot water a day or less. The gain is smaller for households using much more. ENERGY STAR gives a typical life of about 20 years for gas tankless units, longer than a conventional tank, which commonly lasts a decade or so and varies with water quality and care.

TankTankless
Hot water supplyLimited by tank size, then recovery timeContinuous, limited by flow rate
Standby heat lossYesNone
Typical lifespanRoughly a decade or moreAbout 20 years for gas units (ENERGY STAR)
SpaceFloor space for a tankWall-mounted, compact
Upfront and install costLowerHigher, especially if gas or venting changes
UpkeepFlush, check anode rod and valveFlush to remove scale, clean inlet filter
Power outageGas models may still work depending on designMost need electricity to run

What size tankless water heater do I need for 3 bathrooms?

Size by flow rate, in gallons per minute, not by tank gallons. Add up the fixtures that could run at the same time. ENERGY STAR lists typical flows of 2.5 gallons per minute for a shower, 3.3 for a clothes washer, 2.2 for a sink and 1.3 for a dishwasher. Two showers and a dishwasher together come to about 6.3, so a three-bathroom home usually needs a larger unit or two units.

Temperature rise also matters. The unit has to heat incoming water from its cold temperature to the setpoint, and colder incoming water means lower flow at the same output. A plumber considers your incoming water temperature, your peak use and whether any units can be staged. ENERGY STAR advises asking an installer to confirm the right flow rate, whether the existing gas line is large enough, whether power is nearby for models with powered venting and how the gases will be vented.

Households that often run two showers and a washer at once may prefer two tankless units or a large tank. Single users with a short shower habit can do well with a smaller unit.

How long do tankless water heaters last, and what upkeep do they need?

Gas tankless heaters are rated at roughly 20 years in ENERGY STAR material, provided they are maintained. The main upkeep is flushing the heat exchanger to remove mineral scale, which builds faster in hard water, and cleaning the inlet filter. Tank heaters need a flush, a check of the pressure relief valve and an anode rod inspection.

Skipping upkeep shortens the life of either type. The tankless water heater flush page explains the steps, and for tanks, see flushing a water heater and the anode rod replacement guide. Tank units also fail by leaking when the tank wall corrodes through.

What does installation involve for each type?

A tank swap is often the simpler job when the new unit fits the same spot, uses the same fuel and the same connections. California requires water heaters to be braced or strapped against earthquakes, and a permit is common for replacements. Ask the plumbing business whether it pulls the permit and arranges the inspection.

Size comparison of a tank and a tankless water heater

A tankless install often involves more. A gas unit may need a larger gas line and a different vent. An electric tankless unit draws a heavy electrical load, so the panel and the circuit must handle it. Moving from a tank to tankless can mean new vent routing, a condensate drain, isolation valves and a new wall mount. The page on gas versus electric water heaters compares fuels. Gas line work requires a California contractor license, so it is not a DIY job.

If you use propane, ask how a unit will be fed. A small portable cylinder is unlikely to keep a whole-house unit supplied, and the plumber can size a larger tank or confirm a natural gas connection.

What should you compare in quotes?

Compare the unit's rated output and fuel, what the price includes (venting, gas line changes, permit, disposal of the old heater, isolation valves, expansion tank), the written warranty on parts and labor and what the business expects from you. Prices vary widely with the home, so a plumber quotes after a site visit.

For ranges, see water heater cost and tankless water heater cost. If your unit is leaking or has failed, the water heater repair plumber page covers the repair side. Ready to compare? Request quotes and mention how many bathrooms and fixtures you run at once.

Questions people ask

What are the main advantages and drawbacks of tankless water heaters?

Advantages: endless hot water within the flow limit, no standby loss, a compact wall unit and a long expected life. Drawbacks: a higher purchase and install price, possible gas, venting or electrical upgrades, a flow limit with several fixtures running and a need for regular descaling, especially with hard water.

Is tankless worth it for a small household?

It can be. Households that use less hot water see the biggest percentage savings from tankless, according to the Department of Energy, but lower use also means the dollar savings take longer to repay the higher price. A plumber can estimate with your fuel and usage.

Is electric or gas tankless better?

Gas units deliver higher flow and suit larger homes, but need venting and gas supply. Electric units are simpler to vent but pull a large electrical load and may need a panel upgrade. Fuel availability, utility rates and your panel capacity decide the question for your house.

Will a tankless water heater work in a power outage?

Most need electricity for controls, fans and ignition, so they stop when power fails. Some tank models with a standing pilot keep working. Ask about battery or generator options if outages are a concern.

Does a tankless heater need a permit in California?

A water heater replacement commonly needs a plumbing permit, and moving to tankless with new venting or gas work normally does. Rules are set locally, so ask the plumbing business to confirm the permit and inspection for your address.

Sources

Last changed